\( \newcommand{\N}{\mathbb{N}} \newcommand{\Z}{\mathbb{Z}} \newcommand{\R}{\mathbb{R}} \newcommand{\measure}[1]{\operatorname{m}{#1}} \newcommand{\segment}[1]{\overline{#1}} \newcommand{\ray}[1]{\vec{#1}} \newcommand{\mAngle}[1]{\measure{\angle{#1}}} \newcommand{\mSegment}[1]{\measure{\segment{#1}}} \)

Schedule

Note: Grades have been tallied and submitted to the registrar. This is the final update of this page (so links may be broken, people of the future).

Students: Thank you for a great semester, and wish you all the best of luck in your future endeavours!

Final update: Tuesday, 9 May 2023 at 12:00.

Purpose of this Page

Here is a complete list of topics for History of Mathematics (math330-e23) organized by lecture. As the semester progresses I add additional content, study suggestions, and descriptions. If you are in the course, you should bookmark this page and check back often.

For more information about the course, see our class homepage.

For a detailed schedule from the college, see the academic calendar.

Lecture 01

Tuesday, 17 January 2023

Syllabus

Discussed the syllabus.

  • Assignments for the semester.
  • Using LaTeX for all assignments.
  • Grade breakdown and deadlines.

Mathematical Preferences

Because I will be tailoring this class to the interests of the students, we spent a significant portion of this lecture discussing the backgrounds and preferences of the students. We talked a lot about what some of the broad disciplines encompass (Topology, Analysis, Algebra, Combinatorics). We also determined that we want to learn more about the history of calculus, and if possible, incorporate some work on mathematics in nature into the course. I promised to think about how to do this.

Homework

HW 00
Respond to my welcome email.
HW 01
Choose a term paper subject (deadline).

Lecture 02

Thursday, 19 January 2023

Using LaTeX

This lecture was a live-coding session describing how to use LaTeX for this course. I suggested students use Overleaf for their projects for the time being, and ask me if they encounter much difficulty.

I also wrote notes on using LaTeX that describe in some detail what different parts of the code do, and how to obtain pretty results. That page also links all the LaTeX that I produced, so you can test it out on your own if you so choose. I strongly recommend that students read that page carefully.

Homework

Due 00
Did you respond to my email?

Lecture 03

Tuesday, 24 January 2023

Ancient Counting Systems

  • Ishango bone.
  • Egyptian arithmetic systems.
  • Ionian numeric symbolism.

Homework

Due 01
Turn in your top three subject choices for your term paper.

Lecture 04

Thursday, 26 January 2023

Ancient Arithmetic Systems

  • Babylonian arithmetic
    • Base 60
    • Positional system!

We also had a modern description of the mathematics of representations of real numbers in base \( b \).

Base \( b \) Representation
For every \( b \in \Z_{\geq 2} \) and every \( x \in \R \) there is are \( 0 \leq p_k < b \) for which \( x = \sum_{k \in \Z} p_k b^k \).

Finally, we gave a sketch of the proof of this result in the case \( x \in \Z \).

Homework

Annotated Bibliography

Create an annotated bibliography for your term paper (deadline).

Reading

Download a copy of Euclid's Elements. That link has both the Ancient Greek and an English translation side-by-side. For Tuesday, read the sections entitled

  • Definitions,
  • Postulates,
  • Common Notions, and
  • Proposition 1.

Lecture 05

Tuesday, 31 January 2023

Early Greek Geometry

Thales of Miletus

  • First statements of abstract theorems.
  • Didn't leave any of his own writings.
  • Marks a shift (in his locale) towards abstract reasoning and proof.

Pythagoras of Samos

  • Cult leader who liked geometry.
  • His school was a major influence in the development of education through the middle ages (e.g., their four subjects of study are the first four liberal arts).
  • Connections between numbers and geometric concepts.

We proved some simple number-theoretic results about triangle and square numbers using historical methods.

Lecture 06

Thursday, 2 February 2023

I had to cancel this lecture. Students were instructed to use this time to study and prepare their bibliographies.

Lecture 07

Tuesday, 7 February 2023

I had to cancel this lecture. Students were instructed to use this time to study and prepare their bibliographies.

Lecture 08

Thursday, 9 February 2023

Euclid and The Elements

Don't forget to download a copy of Euclid's Elements before lecture!

I've created a reference sheet of modern "translations" of Euclid's propositions for students. I suggest keeping this handy as we progress through the Elements.

  • Discussed some historical context for Euclid's work.
  • Read through the Definitions, Postulates, and Common Notions together. This included a discussion of more recent terminology by comparison to Euclid's.

Homework

Annotated Bibliography Due

Turn in the annotated bibliography for your term paper.

Preliminary Report on Mathematics

Write a preliminary report on the mathematics for your term paper (deadline).

Lecture 09

Tuesday, 14 February 2023

Euclid and The Elements

We discussed some of the implicit assumptions (i.e., hidden postulates) Euclid makes. We also followed along with the constructions in GeoGebra.

See the reference sheet of propositions.

Proposition 1

Let \( A \) and \( B \) be distinct points. There is a point \( C \) for which \( \triangle{ABC} \) is an equilateral triangle.

Proposition 2

Let \( A \), \( B \), and \( C \) be points. There is a point \( D \) for which \( \mSegment{AD} = \mSegment{BC} \).

Proposition 3

Let \( A \), \( B \), \( C \), and \( D \) be points. If \( \mSegment{AB} \leq \mSegment{CD} \), then there is a point \( E \in \segment{CD} \) with \( \mSegment{CE} = \mSegment{AB} \).

Lecture 10

Thursday, 16 February 2023

Euclid and The Elements

Proposition 4

Let \( \triangle{ABC} \) and \( \triangle{DEF} \) be given. If \( \mSegment{AB} = \mSegment{DE} \), \( \mSegment{AC} = \mSegment{DF} \), and \( \mAngle{BAC} = \mAngle{EDF} \), then \( \triangle{ABC} \cong \triangle{DEF} \).

Proposition 5

Let \( A \), \( B \), and \( C \) be non-collinear points. If \( \mSegment{AB} = \mSegment{AC} \), then \( \mAngle{ABC} = \mAngle{ACB} \).

Lecture 11

Tuesday, 21 February 2023

Euclid and The Elements

Proposition 6

Let \( A \), \( B \), and \( C \) be non-collinear points. If \( \mAngle{ABC} = \mAngle{ACB} \), then \( \mSegment{AB} = \mSegment{AC} \).

Proposition 7

Let \( A \), \( B \), \( C \), and \( D \) be points. Assume \( \mSegment{AC} = \mSegment{AD} \) and \( \mSegment{BC} = \mSegment{BD} \). If \( C \) and \( D \) are on the same side of \( AB \), then \( C = D \).

Proposition 8

Let \( \triangle{ABC} \) and \( \triangle{DEF} \) be given. If \( \mSegment{AB} = \mSegment{DE} \), \( \mSegment{BC} = \mSegment{EF} \), and \( \mSegment{CA} = \mSegment{FD} \), then \( \mAngle{ABC} = \mAngle{DEF} \).

Lecture 12

Thursday, 23 February 2023

Euclid and The Elements

Proposition 9

Let \( A \), \( B \), and \( C \) be non-collinear points. There is a point \( D \) in the interior of \( \angle{BAC} \) with \( \mAngle{BAD} = \mAngle{CAD} \).

Proposition 10

Let \( A \) and \( B \) be points. There is a point \( C \in \segment{AB} \) with \( \mSegment{AC} = \mSegment{BC} \).

Proposition 11

Let \( A \), \( B \), and \( C \) be distinct points. If \( C \in \segment{AB} \), then there is a point \( D \) with \( CD \perp AB \).

Homework

HW 12
Write a preliminary biographical report on your subject for your term paper (deadline).

Lecture 130

Tuesday, 28 February 2023

Euclid and The Elements

Proposition 12

Let \( A \), \( B \), and \( C \) be non-collinear points. There is a point \( D \) with \( AB \perp CD \).

Proposition 13

Let \( A \), \( B \), \( C \), and \( D \) be distinct points. If \( B \in \segment{CD} \), then the sum of the angles \( \angle{CBA} \) and \( \angle{ABD} \) is the same in measure as the sum of two right angles.

Proposition 14

Let \( A \), \( B \), \( C \), and \( D \) be distinct points. If \( C \) and \( D \) are on opposite sides of \( AB \) and the sum of \( \angle{ABC} \) and \( \angle{ABD} \) is the same in measure as the sum of two right angles, then \( B \in \segment{CD} \).

Lecture 14

Thursday, 2 March 2023

Euclid and The Elements

See the reference sheet of propositions.

If students said it was OK to put their name on the website, I've marked their presentation as a guest lecture with their name. Otherwise, I marked them "Anonymous" or "Secret".

Proposition 15 (lecture by Will)

Let \( A \), \( B \), \( C \), and \( D \) be distinct points. If \( E \in \mSegment{AB} \cap \mSegment{CD} \), then \( \mAngle{AEC} = \mAngle{BED} \).

Proposition 16

Let \( \triangle{ABC} \) be given and \( D \neq C \). If \( C \in BD \), then \( \mAngle{ACD} > \mAngle{CBA} \) and \( \mAngle{ACD} > \mAngle{BAC} \).

Proposition 17 (lecture by Anonymous)

Let \( \triangle{ABC} \) be given. The sum of \( \angle{ABC} \) and \( \angle{ACB} \) is less in measure than the sum of two right angles.

Proposition 18 (lecture by Martha)

Let \( \triangle{ABC} \) be given. If \( \mSegment{AB} < \mSegment{BC} \), then \( \mAngle{ACB} < \mAngle{BAC} \).

Lecture 15

Tuesday, 7 March 2023

Euclid and The Elements

Proposition 19 (lecture by Secret)

Let \( \triangle{ABC} \) be given. If \( \mAngle{ACB} < \mAngle{BAC} \), then \( \mSegment{AB} < \mSegment{BC} \).

Proposition 20 (lecture by Franny)

Let \( \triangle{ABC} \) be given. Then the sum of the segments \( \segment{AB} \) and \( \segment{BC} \) is greater in measure than the segment \( \segment{BC} \).

Proposition 21

Let \( \triangle{ABC} \) be given. If \( D \) is in the interior of \( \triangle{ABC} \), then \( \mSegment{BD} < \mSegment{AB} \) and \( \mAngle{BAC} < \mAngle{BDC} \).

Proposition 22

Let \( \alpha \), \( \beta \), and \( \gamma \) be segments. If the measure of the pairwise sums of these segments always exceed the measure of the remaining segment, then there is a triangle with sides equal in measure to \( \alpha \), \( \beta \), and \( \gamma \).

Proposition 23 (lecture by Nicole)

Let \( A \), \( B \), \( C \), \( D \), and \( E \) be points with \( C \), \( D \), and \( E \) non-collinear. There is a point \( F \) with \( \mAngle{FAB} = \mAngle{DCE} \).

Homework

Preliminary Maths Report Due

Turn in the preliminary maths report for your term paper.

Lecture 16

Tuesday, 21 March 2023

Euclid and The Elements

Proposition 24

Let \( \triangle{ABC} \) and \( \triangle{DEF} \) be given. If \( \mSegment{AB} = \mSegment{DE} \), \( \mSegment{AC} = \mSegment{DF} \), and \( \mAngle{BAC} > \mAngle{EDF} \), then \( \mSegment{BC} > \mSegment{EF} \).

Proposition 26

Let \( \triangle{ABC} \) and \( \triangle{DEF} \) be given. Assume \( \mAngle{ABC} = \mAngle{DEF} \) and \( \mAngle{BCA} = \mAngle{EFD} \). If either \( \mSegment{BC} = \mSegment{EF} \) or \( \mSegment{AB} = \mSegment{DE} \), then \( \triangle{ABC} \cong \triangle{DEF} \).

Lecture 17

Thursday, 23 March 2023

Euclid and The Elements

Proposition 25 (lecture by Tashinga)

Let \( \triangle{ABC} \) and \( \triangle{DEF} \) be given. If \( \mSegment{AB} = \mSegment{DE} \), \( \mSegment{AC} = \mSegment{DF} \), and \( \mSegment{BC} > \mSegment{EF} \), then \( \mAngle{BAC} > \mAngle{EDF} \).

Proposition 27

Let lines \( AB \), \( CD \), and \( EF \) be given with \( E \in \segment{AB} \) and \( F \in \segment{CD} \). If \( \mAngle{AEF} = \mAngle{EFD} \), then \( AB \parallel CD \).

Proposition 28

Let distinct lines \( AB \), \( CD \), and \( EF \) be given so that no three of these points are collinear. Assume there are points \( G \in \segment{AB} \cap \segment{EF} \) and \( H \in \segment{CD} \cap \segment{EF} \). If either \( \mAngle{EGB} = \mAngle{GHD} \) or the measure of the sum of \( \angle{BGH} \) and \( \angle{DHG} \) is equal to that of two right angles, then \( AB \parallel CD \).

Lecture 18

Tuesday, 28 March 2023

Euclid and The Elements

Proposition 29

Let distinct lines \( AB \), \( CD \), and \( EF \) be given so that no three of these points are collinear. Assume there are points \( G \in \segment{AB} \cap \segment{EF} \) and \( H \in \segment{CD} \cap \segment{EF} \). If \( AB \parallel CD \), then the sum of the angles \( \angle{BGH} \) and \( \angle{GHD} \) is equal in measure with the sum of two right angles.

Proposition 30

If lines \( \alpha \parallel \beta \) and \( \beta \parallel \gamma \), then \( \alpha \parallel \gamma \). That is, parallelism is a transitive relation on lines.

Proposition 31

Let \( A \), \( B \), and \( C \) be non-collinear points. There is a line \( \ell \) with \( A \in \ell \) and \( \ell \parallel BC \).

Summary of the Reminder of Book 1

We briefly sketched the structure of the remainder of Book 1. Mostly it's about…

  • areas of parallelograms,
  • areas of triangles, and
  • constructions of rectangles and squares.

Proposition 47

The Pythagorean Theorem!

We looked briefly at Euclid's proof, to appreciate the complexity and delicacy of his argument. However, we gave a complete argument using Reverend Wheeler's proof.

Homework

HW 18
Write the first draft of your term paper (deadline).

Lecture 19

Thursday, 30 March 2023

The Euclidean Scandal

The Parallel Postulate and non-euclidean(!) geometries.

  • Equivalent axioms to the parallel postulate.
  • Euclid's historical influence on academia and education.
  • Attempts to prove the parallel postulate.
  • The Poincare Disk model and NON-EUCLIDEAN GEOMETRY!!!

Lecture 20

Tuesday, 4 April 2023

Archimedes and the Method of Exhaustion

Discussed Archimedes and some of his mathematics.

Life

  • Born in Syracuse, Sicily. Killed during a Roman invasion. Lived 287–212 BCE.
  • Studied in Alexandria, Egypt at the great Library.
  • Genius inventor.
  • All around cool dude (if a bit smelly).

Mathematics

Determined a formula for the area of the circle—the formula given is the . The key ingredients to his argument (see your lecture notes) were:

  • The ratio of the circumference to the diameter is a constant (in Euclidean geometry). Today we call that constant \( \pi \).
  • The area and perimeter of all regular \( n \)-gons.
  • Every circle has an inscribed square (Euclid 4.6).
  • Eudoxus' Method of Exhaustion (this can be understood as a rudimentary version of limits).
  • Areas are always comparable (i.e., exactly one of \( A < B \) or \( A = B \) or \( A > B \) always holds).
  • Proof by contradiction.

Archimedes' argument recovers Euclid 12.2. His argument is "non-constructive" in an interesting way: it compares the area of the circle with that of a triangle whose existence is merely postulated, rather than constructed by Euclidean means. This has the advantage that it works—the specific triangle he used cannot be constructed with Euclid's axioms alone!

Homework

Due 12
Turn in the preliminary biographical report for your term paper.

Lecture 21

Thursday, 6 April 2023

Interlude: Time Skip!

Discussed some patterns in the developments in mathematics around the world over the next 1800 years. This lecture was mostly historical content (with some mathematical examples, but no proofs).

  • Number as abstract quantity.
  • Algebra's invention.
  • Invention of negative numbers.
  • Symbolic notation's development.
  • Development of analytic methods for geometry.

Lecture 22

Tuesday, 11 April 2023

Newton and the Inverse Method of Fluxions

Mathematics

  • Invented the calculus, though not in the form we currently see it.
  • Invented the binomial series!
  • Used calculus to study optics, planetary motion, projectile motion, and much more.

We saw in lecture Newton's approach to approximating \( \pi \). This involved several key components.

  1. The binomial series yields an approximation of \( \sqrt{3} \) to arbitrary (finite) precision.
  2. The semicircle \( 0 \leq y \leq \sqrt{x(1-x)} \) has area approximation from \( x = 0 \) to \( x = \tfrac{1}{4} \) using the "Method of Inverse Fluxions" (i.e., Newton's integral).
  3. The same portion of the semicircle has a geometric area approximation via sectors!
  4. Finally, comparing the true value and using our approximated values (to only \( 9 \) terms!) we can approximate \( \pi \) to \( 7 \) decimal places.

Homework

Due 18
Turn in the first draft of your term paper.

Lecture 23

Thursday, 13 April 2023

Leibniz and Infinite Series

  • Discussed Leibniz as a historical figure.
  • Computed the sum of the geometric series.
  • Computed the sum of the reciprocals of the triangular numbers.
  • Discussed how the methods weren't totally rigorous, and how this wouldn't change for a long time.

Homework

HW 23
Write the revised draft of your term paper (deadline).

Lecture 24

Tuesday, 18 April 2023

Brothers Bernoulli

  • Discussed Jakob and Johann Bernoulli as historical figures. This included a number of anecdotes about what great friends they were (sike).
  • Gave the Bernoulli's proof that the harmonic series diverges.
  • Discussed some shortcomings of the original proof, and formalized the proof in modern language.

Lecture 25

Thursday, 20 April 2023

Euler

  • Long discussion of Euler's mathematics and his historical precedence.
  • We took a diversion to discuss some topology, to explain the Euler characteristic.
  • Gave Euler's proof that \( \sum_{k=0}^\infty \frac{1}{n^2} = \frac{\pi^2}{6} \).

Lecture 26

Tuesday, 25 April 2023

Euler's (and Fermat's) Number Theory

Homework

Due 23
Turn in the revised draft of your term paper.

Lecture 27

Thursday, 27 April 2023

Georg Cantor and Infinity

  • Fermat's Method of Infinite Descent and Mathematical Induction as a spur for reinventing logic in maths.
  • Georg Cantor's reinvention of mathematics by set theory.
  • Cardinality (i.e., sizes of sets) thought of via pairings (i.e., functions).
  • Paradoxes in cardinality (countable sets).

Homework

HW 27
Write the final draft of your term paper (deadline).

Lecture 28

Tuesday, 2 May 2023

Infinity and Beyond

  • Cantor's diagonalization argument and the hierarchy of infinities.

Charlotte Angus Scott

Nicole gave a short lecture on Charlotte Angus Scott, including a discussion of some ideas in projective geometry from Note on the geometrical treatment of conics, Ann. of Math. (2) 2 (1-4) 1900, 64-72.

Interested folks might also see a list of her publications (or my MathSciNet BibTeX export) and her entry in this biography (which also includes a list of other sources, both mathy and biographical).

Ada Lovelace

Franny gave a short lecture on Ada Lovelace, including a discussion of her work on the Difference and Analytical Engines pioneered by Lovelace and Charles Babbage.

Interested folks might also see this biography and a repository of her correspondences.

Final Deadline

Thursday, 4 May 2023 is a reading day.

We have a scheduled final exam time for Friday, 5 May 2023 at 09:00 because our class happens during Canonical Hour M (see the Canonical Class Meeting Hours). See the Final Exam schedule for the College of Arts and Sciences for more information.

Note: If what is written here conflicts with the official schedule, the official university page takes precedence for final exam times.

David Blackwell

Tashinga gave a short lecture on David Blackwell, including a discussion of the Rao-Blackwell Theorem from Conditional Expectation and Unbiased Sequential Estimation, Ann. Math. Statist. 18 (1) 105 - 110, March, 1947.

Interested folks might also see this biographical sketch and the list of his publications I pulled from MathSciNet.

Karl Weierstrass

Quinn gave a short lecture on Karl Weierstrass, including a construction of a continuous, nowhere-differentiable function.

Interested folks might also read a biographical sketch, about his contributions developing the calculus, and see the list of his publications I pulled from MathSciNet.

Claude Shannon

Will gave a short lecture on Claude Shannon, including a summary of various aspects of his contributions to mathematics and computer science.

Interested folks might also see this biographical and mathematical sketch, the Library of Congress Guide to Shannon's papers and the list of his publications I pulled from MathSciNet.

Ashutosh Mukherjee

Martha gave a short lecture on Ashutosh Mukherjee, including a sketch of his solution to the problem of finding oblique trajectories to systems of confocal ellipses from On the differential equations of a trajectory, Jour. of Asiatic Soc., Bengal, Vol.56, Pt.II, No.1, pp.117–120, 1887.

Interested folks might also see this biographical and mathematical sketch (which includes a list of published works).

Term Paper

Friday, 5 May 2023

Turn in the final draft of your term paper during our scheduled final time.